How to sell your used fashion online | Alexandra Stylist | Personal Wardrobe Stylist

How to sell your used fashion online

By | June 9th, 2015 | Confessions

One of the things my clients always ask is what to do with their stuff once they’re done with it. Is there a good place to sell it all?


The online world has decided that consignment is best served – online. What used to be a chore of schlepping your stuff around to various consignment shops and direct pay places like Buffalo Exchange has now turned into a much more seamless experience, thanks to a lot of new options available in the online selling arena.

In the past 2 years I’ve seen a big rush of new companies approach me wanting to sell my clients’ high end designer, never-been-worn wares (especially accessories) – online.

It’s like they all got the same idea at once!

I decided to try out some of these services to see the level of customer service they offer. Here are the results:


These guys are super selective about the pieces they take. I left a full bag for them with my doorman and they only took a few items. Over the next months I’d get a small check here and there. Always around $50 -$70. Nothing that crazy.

2. I-ella (now out of business)

I created an online closet profile and sent them what I thought would sell. Visitors could then ‘shop my closet’. My ‘closet’ even made it to ‘featured stylist profile’.

They did sell a few of my items but the majority got sent back to me. What I made was nominal ($93.75 for 2 items out of 25 sent).


I posted my Vivienne Westwood peplum jacket on eBay. It was fairly easy to do.

The first auction didn’t meet its reserve price. After re-listing, it got bought by a woman in Ukraine for $101 (including the shipping fee).

4. ThredUp

ThredUp are focused on mid level brands (LOFT, Banana Republic etc.) but prefer near-new pieces or items with tags still attached. I sent a huge bag off to them (they covered shipping), but they didn’t take a single thing. I had some nice brands but all items had been worn before so I think that’s why they passed.

Then I had to pay a flat fee to have it shipped back and find new homes for those unlucky items. Kinda a bummer.

5. Cashinmybag

This site bases their business model on gold-for-cash mail order. Debbie Blank claims they are different from the others because they pay for the goods up front. Kind of like an online high-end version of Beacon’s Closet.

They contacted me and requested access to my client’s closet discards. I said I would give them a whirl and decide.

I then sent them about 10 personal items for appraisal – all designer accessories in various stages of wear. Shipping cost me $0 and they even provided the box and the label. Here’s what I got back from the appraiser:


I got to decide what to sell just by checking boxes and then get the rest shipped back to me free of charge. Note: if you send them counterfeit items, you will have to pay a fee to get it back. Sorry!

I didn’t get a lot of money per item but they did offer to take everything I sent them off my hands, which I thought was pretty great. I decided to get rid of the whole lot so I got a check for the total amount of $240. Nice and easy.

There are more consignment, resell, and donation resources in my next book Vetted by a Stylist which is entering the final stages as we speak.

Get a sneak peak and the skinny here>>


Related Posts